FREE Subscription The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter   
More Fish Oil, Less Vegetable Oil, Better for Your Health

Including more fish oil than vegetable oil in your diet may help protect your tissues and organs from inflammation, according to University of Michigan researchers.

In your body, both fish oil and vegetable oil are converted into chemicals called prostanoids. Though these compounds help to control blood pressure and prevent allergies, when produced in excess they increase inflammation, pain, swelling, and redness in body tissues.

The researchers found that prostanoids from fish oil and vegetable oil are not the same. Those made from fish oil are “less effective at causing pain and swelling than those made from vegetable oil,” researchers said.

Meanwhile, adding fish oil to your diet effectively decreases the amount of prostanoids made from vegetable oil, though sometimes in unexpected amounts.

In the study, researchers looked at the effects of both fish oil and vegetable oil in cultured cells. Both oils are converted into prostanoids by cyclo-oxygenases (COX) enzymes, types 1 and 2.

In reactions that involved COX-1, if more fish oil was present it bound to COX-1 preferentially and limited vegetable oil’s access to the enzymes. However, in reactions involving COX-2, an increased amount of fish oil did not change the binding process, so more vegetable oil was converted to prostanoids.

The findings suggest that the body naturally regulates levels of prostanoids produced by fish and vegetable oils, but the researchers are still investigating exactly why COX-1 and COX-2 act differently.  

They hope that, upon further investigation, they will be able to design new anti-inflammatory drugs that will bind to COX-2 and decrease the levels of prostanoids from vegetable oils.

Journal of Biological Chemistry August 3, 2007, Vol. 282, Issue 31, 22254-22266

Science Blog July 27, 2007


Dr. Mercola’s Comment:

The central premise of this study is a great one: eating fish oil (omega-3 fats) is far better for your body than eating vegetable oil (omega-6 fats). These findings clearly show yet another reason why maintaining an ideal ratio of omega-3 to omega-6 fats is so important; it will help to reduce painful inflammation in your body.

However, the researchers missed the mark on their ultimate goal to develop more anti-inflammatory drugs. Rather than recommending the intuitive solution -- that you could benefit from getting more fish oil, and less vegetable oil, in your diet -- they are looking to develop drugs to lessen the potentially harmful effects of vegetable oil.

Vegetable oils like corn, soy, safflower, and canola are the worst oils you can eat. They are problematic not only because they easily become oxidized or rancid when exposed to heat from cooking, but also because Americans are consuming them in unprecedented amounts -- up to 100 times greater than in the past.

The ideal ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 fats is 1:1. This is what your ancestors thrived on for millions of years. Today, largely as a result of consuming far too many omega-6 fats and too few omega-3 fats, our ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 averages from 20:1 to 50:1!

You may not think that you use much vegetable oil from day to day, however if you eat processed foods you are consuming large amounts of vegetable oils. The vast majority of foods on your supermarket shelves -- from tomato sauce to bread -- contain them.

Consuming too many vegetable oils has been linked to:

To get your omega-6 to omega-3 ratio closer to the ideal 1:1, simply cut back on all vegetable oils (you’ll need to read labels if you eat processed foods) and get a regular supply of high-quality omega-3 fat, like that from krill oil, daily.

And remember, if you’re struggling with pain from inflammation, you can avoid the serious risks of anti-inflammatory drugs by trying out these natural anti-inflammatory alternatives instead. If you want a quick hint, omega-3 fat, which is known to effectively fight inflammation, is one excellent option.

Related Articles:




Did you find this article interesting?
Article's Comment     ( 12 Comments )
 
 
 +5 Points           
 
Author of the Article
BY Bridestein   
  
[ Joined on 12/06 ]
[ Posted on July 31, 2007 ]
Post Reply
And they're using this information to develop new drugs, instead of just recommending that people consume fish oil instead of vegetable oil?!?!?

 
 +2 Points           
 
Author of the Article
BY Bob2_203   
  
[ Joined on 06/06 ]
[ Posted on August 02, 2007 ]
Post Reply
I agree with much of the article, but I finally have to go on record as being against omega-3 supplementation.   ALL polyunsaturates are hazardous to health, longevity, and well-being.   They are too damaging to human (and animal) tissue.   Whether omega-3 or omega-6, it matters little.   Both negatively alter hormone balance, suppress thyroid, lower immunity, increase weight, and cause massive free radical damage.   It's madness to go out of the way to find and consume refined fish oil of any kind.

Omega-3 supplementation is counter to good health.   I know this is in opposition with what Dr. Mercola believes, and probably most of this forum, but there it is.   If an oil becomes sticky at 98.6 degrees in the presence of oxygen, it becomes sticky in your body, with the attendant ill-effects

The designation of “essential” fatty acids is a misnomer.   They body will synthesize the exact amounts and types of polyunsaturates that it needs, if any, providing there is enough quality dietary saturated fat.   Note that most commercial animal fat is increasingly polyunsaturated due to being fed nothing but corn and soy.   The best sources of fat for human consumption are coconut oil, grass-fed butter (whether it’s pasteurized or not matters not, as it’s mostly fat), and extra virgin olive oil.

Sorry if this ruffles anyone's feathers.

 

 +2 Points           
 
Author of the Article
BY Amanda Rose   
  
[ Joined on 06/06 ]
Author of the Article [ Posted on August 18, 2007 ]
 
agave -- We need to take a two-pronged strategy with food: reduce the Omega 6s and then we will need less Omega 3 fatty acid. As it is, most of us probably need supplements because our Omega 6 intake is so high. There is still decent seafood out there, though I agree it is becoming increasingly difficult to know what is safe. The Ocean's Alive site is a good resource.

Amanda

 +2 Points           
 
Author of the Article
BY Amanda Rose   
  
[ Joined on 06/06 ]
Author of the Article [ Posted on August 13, 2007 ]
 
Bob -- the big issue here is the balance of Omega 6 to Omega 3 fatty acids which is important regardless of saturated fat intake. Supplementation is a good option for people who have an imbalance and want relief from related ailments as soon as possible ( depression and omega 3 ; Alzheimers and Omega 3 ). A long term diet change is a better idea.

Amanda

 -1 Points           
 
Author of the Article
BY agavesyrup   
  
[ Joined on 07/07 ]
Author of the Article [ Posted on August 02, 2007 ]
 
I totally agree with trying to improve your omega-3 and 6 ratio but the question for many people is how.       If you increase your fish intake, you also increase you mercury levels.     Farm raised fish doesn't have the omega-3 levels that wild fish have......salmon especially.     Fish oil supplements in my opinion are the safest and easiest way to increase your omega-3 levels safely.       I take about 2.5 grams of omega-3 fish oil daily in an enteric coated capsule......no fish burp!    I also take flax seeds for the small amount of omega-3 it provides, the fantastic insoluble fiber, and the powerful antioxidants called lignans.

 
 +2 Points           
 
Author of the Article
BY